Mc Pheeters Antique Militaria
Home Page About Us Ordering Information Links

 

     

1889 FRANCIS BANNERMAN’S SALES CATALOG LISTING FOR A GROUP OF GUNS SURRENDERED BY SITTING BULL:  Several years ago from a large private research library I purchased what I believe is an original 1889 Francis Bannerman sales catalog.  It is the small format catalog, measuring 8 ¼” by 5 ¼”, which featured the latest additions to his inventory.   

Other than a cursory glance through it at the time, I didn't read the text for any detail until recently when looking for a reference on something and I had run out of options.  Spying the catalog on the book shelf, and thinking Bannerman may have offered something similar through the years, I began browsing through the pages.  There I found an innocuous listing for what was probably the one of the most significant offerings that ever passed through Bannerman’s hands.   

Buried on page 7, between bold large type face listings for CW "bombshells", Dragoon Horse Pistols ($2 ea. for what was probably the M1855 Pistol Carbines WITH the shoulder stocks) and Reindeer Skin fur coats from the Greeley Arctic Relief Expedition, lay a listing in small plain type face for a “Lot of 50 Assorted Rifles, Muskets, and Carbines, part of the lot surrendered by the Indian Chief Sitting Bull to the U.S. Government after the Custer Massacre”.   

The description is fairly cursory, but it does mention that some of the stocks are repaired with buckskin and that some of the arms are still loaded.   The casual nature of the listing and its location deep within the catalog with no special effort to highlight the listing or draw customers’ attention to it is only overshadowed by the prices indicated:  $3-$5 each - except for "some" Henry rifles in the group which are priced at a staggering $7 each.  Imagine being able to buy the entire lot for less than $350……plus the shipping, of course.   

Framing this offering within the historical timeline of the Little Big Horn, Sitting Bull’s subsequent escape into Canada and his eventual return to the United States to surrender, this catalog listing was published less than eight years after Sitting Bull turned these guns over to the government officials and just over a year before the Hunkpapa leader was killed at the Standing Rock Reservation.   

This listing is the sort of thing that dreams are made of – if only we were able to slip back in time for an afternoon with a couple of pockets full of cash...........  Unfortunately, as a friend observed after seeing this listing, so much of the interesting inventory that passed through Bannerman’s stores were purchased solely for their utilitarian value at the time, with no thought to preserving the provenance of the piece, and if they exist today, they are just another old piece of unidentified “stuff”.   

The photographs are provided below are for your enjoyment.  The catalog is not for sale. 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Ordering Instructions

Identified Items  

Firearms

Edged Weapons

Saddles and Horse Equipment

Accoutrements

Collectors Ammunition

Uniforms, Insignia, Hats

Canteens and Mess Gear

Gun tools, Bullet molds and Parts

Field Equipment and Artillery

Original Ordnance Manuals, and Photos 

US Army Medical

Reference Books and Reprints